Lincoln’s Speeches (pp. 23-33)
Introduction by Brook Thomas, pp. 23-4
- What
is the etymological root of “nation”?
- How
did those in the South who seceded from the Union interpret the
Constitution to legitimate their succession?
- What
was Lincoln’s interpretation of the Constitution?
- In
what way was the Civil War a battle over whether we should say “The United
States is” or “The United States are”?
First Inaugural Address (pp. 25-30)
- When
did Lincoln deliver this speech? (date and occasion)
- When Lincoln delivered his speech, seven
states had seceded but war had not yet broken out. He refused to recognize
any right to secession and tried to hold the Union together. Two issues
that concerned the secessionists were slavery and states’ rights. What
does he say about both?
- In
denying the states the rights to secede, Lincoln argues that the Union is
perpetual. How does he justify his argument?
- According
to Lincoln, his duty under the Constitution is “to take care … that the
laws of the Union be faithfully executed in all the states” (p. 27). What,
in practice, does this mean in terms of secession?
- What
is Lincoln describing when he uses the word “country” (p.29)?
- What
is Lincoln’s plea in the last paragraph (p. 30)? What are some pathos
or emotion-words that Lincoln uses in his conclusion?
Second Inaugural Address (pp. 31-32)
- When
did Lincoln deliver this speech? What was the state of the war when he
delivered it?
- As the
almost certain victor in the war, Lincoln could have placed all the blame
for the war on the south. Does he?
- Lincoln
finds common elements, even as they waged war with one another. What are
they?
- Why,
according to Lincoln, did God give “to both North and South, this terrible
war” (p. 32)
- What
is the purpose of the last sentence of the penultimate (next-to-last)
paragraph?
- What
is the purpose of the last paragraph?
Gettysburg Address (p. 33)
- When
did Lincoln deliver this speech? What was the occasion?
- What
event occurred “four score and seven years ago”? (Hint: subtract 87 from
1863.) To which document does Lincoln allude when he says that the “new
nation” was “dedicated to the proposition that all men were created
equal”? Is this consistent with Lincoln’s other speeches?
- The
terms “brought forth” and “conceived” imply birth. Why begin a speech dedicating
a cemetery for the dead with an image of birth? Are there any other images
of birth in the speech?
- How
many times in the speech does Lincoln use a form of the verb “to
dedicate”? What are the different meanings of those uses?
- In the
last paragraph of The Second Inaugural, Lincoln refers to the need “to
finish the work we are in.” In this speech he urges the “living” to be
dedicated to “the unfinished work” of those who died. To what work does he
refer? How is that work like and unlike the “task” or “work” of
nation-building in Virgil?
- In the
last paragraph of the First Inaugural, Lincoln appeals to the “mystic
chords of memory, stretching from every battle field, and patriot grave,
to every living heart and hearthstone” in an effort to preserve the Union.
In the Gettysburg Address, what should the memory of those who are buried
in the graves of this battlefield inspire the living to do?
Discussion Questions
- Nations
can be defined ethnologically as a people bound together by a common
descent and language. They can also be defined politically as a people
bound together by a common government. Which is more accurate of Virgil?
What are the various factors that Lincoln sees binding the American people
into a nation?
- Etymologically
“nation” is cognate with “nativity/birth.” This root meaning would seem to
emphasize the ethnological definition of a nation as a “big family”
descending from a common origin. How does Lincoln supplement that
etymological association in the Gettysburg Address when he links the birth
of the United States to the dedication to the principle of equality?
- In the
Second Inaugural Lincoln acknowledges that slavery was the cause of the
Civil War. Yet in the Gettysburg Address he never mentions slavery. Why do
you think he does not? Even though he does not name slavery, how does he
allude to it?
- For
years, many people in the South referred to the conflict between 1861 and
1865 as the “War between the States,” rather than the Civil War. What is
at stake in this choice of words?