Winchester Cathedral
Winchester Cathedral





Jane Austen's house
Jane Austen's house
Winchester Cathedral
Winchester Cathedral

Austen Lecture #3
"Thinking with" & "Thinking against"

 

I. "Thinking with"
A. Allying with the ironic narrator (in assessing characters, in understanding the necessity to 'hit the mean," etc.)

B. Responding to (cooperating with) generic conventions
1. Expecting a reversal of power and a restored order  NB: When Lady Elliot was alive all was in good order.
2. Recognizing that what looks like an impediment will actually turn out to be a step toward felicity (Wentworth & Louisa Musgrove)(NB: Anne's own statement that Mr. Elliiot has become a positive evil because he impedes her connection with Wentworth.
C. Understanding that Bath is a site for Austen's critique of social rank but also a site for unexpected conjunctions.

The Assesmbly Rooms - Interior
The Assembly Rooms - exterior
The Assembly Rooms - Interior
From Left to Right: The Assembly Rooms--Interior, Exterior, Interior -- Photos by Elizabeth Losh


D. Assessing the Navy: a meritocracy vs. an "ancient and respectable family" (46).

   
E. Defending the Navy

Wars in the background:
The American war 1775
Napoleon
The American war 1814

Tea Room - Assembly Rooms
Octagon Room.  See Persuasion, Part II, Ch. 8
Octagon Room.  See Persuasion, Part II, Ch. 8.
Three views of the Octagon Room in Bath.  See Persuasion, Part II, Ch. 8.
F. Persuasion, with Amanda Root, Ciarán Hinds
Opening scenes:  Look for the parallel & opposition between the "ancient" family and the Navy.

This film is thinking with Austen.


II. "Thinking against"
A. Life on a ship - some details (See "Supporting quotations for Lecture #3 on Austen.")

B. "Jane Austen and Empire" - the Said thesis in Culture and Imperialism (See "Supporting quotations for Lecture #3 on Austen.")


III. "Thinking with" and "Thinking against":
An example

"On quitting the Cobb, they all went indoors with their new friends . . . gratification" (127-8).
"Captain Harville was no reader; but he had contrived excellent accommodations, and fashioned very pretty shelves . . . " (128).